“But the truth is, the world is so much stranger than that.”

Love_&_Monsters‘Love & Monsters’ by Russell T Davies doesn’t have a good reputation. It was the first Doctor-lite episode, the monster design was both too comedic and repulsive and had a joke at the end which was decidedly poor taste.

Regardless I think this is one of the best of Russell T Davies episodes. The comedy works, Elton’s narration is an ingenious framing device and David’s focus on the kitchen sink drama works well in the context of the episode.

In many episodes of Doctor Who we only catch glimpses of ordinary folk and how events are effecting them. Panicked shoppers fleeing Autons, people in the street looking up at giant spaceships hanging over the city or families being marched out of their homes by Cybermen or Daleks.

‘Love & Monsters’ focuses on what happens next for these people. How do they make sense of the strangeness of the world they live in? Later episodes often reveal that the majority buy the cover story of hallucinogens in the water supply or that it was all a hoax.

Elton and the members of LINDA are those that look deeper, who seek meaning in an unaging man named the Doctor and his blue police box.  A whole campaign could be modelled around similar people.

The group could consist of people who have each had a brush with the Doctor, whether it be a close encounter with the man himself or just being caught up in events. The focus of the campaign wouldn’t be combating aliens, UNIT and Torchwood do that already, but instead on just getting by in such a world.

The LINDA meetings change focus during the course of the episode. It starts as people talking about the Doctor but soon they are opening up to each other about their own personal problems, cooking and even forming a Electric Light Orchestra tribute band. At the end of the episode Elton realises that it was during this era of the group that he was happiest and that they were friends.

Such a campaign would be about the real dramas in life. Getting a job, making friends and finding love. Some problems are more serious than others, such as Bridget’s missing drug addicted daughter, but all can lead to interesting dramatic games.

Not that the game needs to be mundane. Elton explains that his life isn’t all aliens and monsters but that it what we see. By editing out the bits in between you can give the impression of a more exciting life without losing sight of the characters humble background.

lindaThe opening of the episode shows many incidents from previous adventures from Elton’s perspective. You could do the same thing, especially if you select an era in which several Doctor Who stories occur in quick succession. You can then skip the weeks, months or years in between as needed, filling in the details of how things have changed for the character in the intervening time at the start of each adventure.

Having a guide to the chronology of the series, such as the excellent AHistory, is ideal for this task. Just glancing at my copy I can see in the last decade alone over 50 events from the television series, books, audios and comics have occurred that could be weaved into the background of on going adventures.

If you can find it Who Killed Kennedy by James Stevens & David Bishop is another example of how to view Doctor Who events from the perspective of an outsider. In this case a journalist investigates the Doctor during the UNIT era. As well as being informative it is also greatly entertaining to catch the references to the particular stories.

You could select a modern setting, choose a historical period or even take it into the realms of science fiction by basing the game during the Earth Empire or near-future so beloved of Virgin’s New Adventures.

In such games the aim is not to defeat the alien of the week. In this game the player characters are bystanders. Instead their goal should be surviving, protecting those they hold dear and maybe finding something out about what is going on. You could also present them with dilemmas such as whether they go to a friends birthday party or investigate a sighting of the TARDIS.

The key is the relationship between the group members. Whether it is researching time lords or playing in a band, working together provides greater results than if they were all acting individually.

Not only can the group achieve results they can strengthen the bonds between them. Two romances develop among the LINDA members and they all care about each other. This is important because not everything can be resolved.

DW20052x10LoveMonsters-00451-1-In Brigit’s case she never does find her missing daughter and at one point Elton muses that he may never know why the Doctor was in his kitchen when he was child. Don’t be afraid to end an adventure without answering all the questions. It can lend an adventure a sense of openness and uncertainty. Maybe they’ll find out what was happening in a later adventure and maybe they won’t. Such is life.

For all its comedic tone ‘Love & Monsters’ has its fair share of darkness. Elton is motivated by the death of his mother, a mystery that persists into his adult life, Brigit has her missing daughter and in the end Elton looses everything he loved about LINDA.

This sadness and loss is tragic and it has its place in an adventure. The player characters can’t save everyone and they can’t always succeed. This darkness only further serves to enhance the significance of their victory . In short a character must fall before he can rise.

The Doctor can act as a very special guest star, his appearances mostly kept to fleeting cameos but in certain adventures he can appear to provide closure for the player characters, explaining what has being happening and putting their lives on track.

They might never travel with him in TARDIS or save the world but their lives are worth living, if only for a short while.

This entry was posted in 10th Doctor, Love & Monsters, Setting. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to “But the truth is, the world is so much stranger than that.”

  1. AngrySmurf says:

    I guess this proves that there’s a fan for just about everything.

    I won’t tell you that your opinion is wrong, it is, after all, your opinion, and as such you are fully entitled to it, but for me personally this is the absolute worst of ‘NuWho’, and probably the only episode that I find almost too painful to even sit through. NuWho has it’s share of mediocre episodes, but in most, just as with the worst of the classic series offerings, I could at least find something to hold on to and enjoy.

    Not with Love & Monsters though. I don’t have a problem with it being ‘Doctor lite’, Turn Left I thought was a fantastic episode, and to be honest, the show could actually use a bit more creativity in the way that it uses The Doctor, rather than always making the character front and center all the time. I just find Love & Monsters just so mind-numbingly awful that it practically defies belief. The only other Who story I rate anywhere near this bad is the truly wretched 7th Doctor story Delta and the Bannermen.

    I will say, however, that most of the performances from the guest cast were pretty solid though, but I’m afraid that’s about as far as it goes for me. I do, however, agree with the underlying point of this blog post that the core idea of using The Doctor almost as a guest star in someone else’s story does hold merrit, and in fact if there is one thing that I wish NuWho would do more often it is for them to realise that with the Doctor Who character and concept they basically have an open ticket to tell any type of story that they want, and that they shouldn’t be afraid of breaking away from formula and exploiting that.

    • etheruk1 says:

      I like Love & Monsters because it has something different to say. There are bad sections which prevent it from being in the best of Who but I still place it higher than some mediocre Who episodes such as ‘Fear Her’, ’42’ or ‘The Lazarus Experiment.’

      Much of the comedy in the episode can be written off due to the fact that it is all being told by Elton who is an unreliable narrator. This would certaintly explain how out of character Rose and the Doctor are when they arrive, berating him rather than dealing with the monster. From Elton’s perspective I’m sure it felt that way.

      Ursula’s final fate is also abhorrent. The idea that the Doctor would condemn someone to that fate is terrible. Considering that those seeking immortality were sentence to a similar ordeal in ‘The Five Doctors’ and that the 9th Doctor made a big deal about everything have a time to die it just doesn’t make sense.

      The plot would actually have worked better if Ursula had died, adding more weight to Elton’s point about remembering the good times.

      What I do like is how clever the script is, the narration allowing us to jump forwards and backwards in the plot, giving things new context. The flash forwards to the fate of the LINDA members and the final section where Elton learns the truth about what happened to his mother and we see old cine film of her letting go of his hand as a boy and vanishing to the sound of ELO’s ‘Mr Blue Sky’ all pack an emotional punch.

      I think it contains some of RTDs best writing. He tones down some of ‘the Doctor is a bringer of death’ theme that started in the first episode of ‘NuWho’ and gives us a more mature view. To quote RTD

      “But the truth is, the world is so much stranger than that. It’s so much darker. And so much madder. And so much better.”

    • etheruk1 says:

      Thanks. Hopefully this is correct now. How embarrassing.

      • Craig Oxbrow says:

        🙂

        Anyway, it is a lovely little episode in parts, as well as a total mess once we get to the big reveal, and a Doctor-Lite Episode with the regular cast all away and a new bunch of poor sods dealing with the wonders and horrors of the Whoniverse would certainly make a good one-shot in a regular game as well as a potential series of its own.

  2. Siskoid says:

    I’m a big fan of L&M… until the last 15 minutes.

    In any case, there are role-playing lessons to be learned from every story, as you prove with every post, whether people like L&M or not.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s